The chapter titled, "Philosophy as a branch of Literature" is one of my favorites. Alongside the passage on p. This is certainly what Collingwood himself thought. His ethical and political views grew somber, and pessimism seemed to overwhelm him.
Yet another inter-connection can be traced from this.
Both are strongly anti-rationalistic in their accounts of the origin of language. Swatting flies with philosophy, or an invitation to hard thinking In the midst of puzzling my way through the abstract concepts of this book I used it to perform at a very concrete function: As I said this is a very high level summary of a key central argument.
The latter will prove to be a mine of information for anyone interested in the origins of analytic philosophy. Contemporary philosophers are not always expert in the development of British anthropology in the inter-war period, so the information that is given on this subject is relevant and useful.
There is, of course, some justification for the stance they take. So it should be said based on this experience that philosophy is both conceptually abstract and functionally concrete and essential to human existenc Review title: Philosophy, says Collingwood, is the attempt to "come to know better what to some extent we knew already" p.
Wittgenstein says in On Certainty that "language does not emerge from reasoning. Collingwood builds his essay sentence upon sentence and paragraph upon paragraph in a continuous logical argument, so no summary could do it justice.
Both will be assets to those libraries which are willing to invest in them. It is worth making the point that Collingwood and Wittgenstein have a great deal in common on these subjects. May 09, R. He felt that the Renaissance had mistakenly separated the various disciplines of study and that a close unity existed among them.
His editing of The Idea of History is particularly unsatisfactory since for many years it led Collingwood scholars up a tortuous garden path. Add to basket Add to wishlist Description An Essay on Philosophical Method contains the most sustained discussion in the twentieth century of the subject matter and method of philosophy and an unparalleled explanation of why philosophy has a distinctive domain of enquiry that differs from that of the sciences of nature.
Malcolm Knox with thanks for help and criticism from R. They were not partners in a common enterprise. But it is only pages long in the modern paperback reprint edition I read, and it can easily be read through in just a couple of days if you have time and environment to focus and think it through as you read.
After all, it is hard to read Wittgenstein without quickly discovering his liking for the tales of the Brothers Grimm or the enthusiastic way he shows us the importance of ritual in human life.
Collingwood also takes some time to mark off what philosophy is not, and how it differs from the sciences and mathematics with which it is often lumped due to proximity of methods and terminology. So it should be said based on this experience that philosophy is both conceptually abstract and functionally concrete and essential to human existence.
What strikes this reviewer from comments by Collingwood scattered throughout this volume is just how much his thinking about the nature of language is closely linked to his discussion of the primitive.
It is also one that has provoked a great deal of disagreement.An Essay on Philosophical Method. Revised Edition. R. G.
Collingwood Edited by James Connelly and Giuseppina D'Oro. A Clarendon Press Publication. It is possible to raise and solve philosophical problems with no very clear idea of what philosophy is, what it is trying to do, and how it can best do it; but no great progress can be made until these questions have been asked and some answer to them given.
Collingwood is the writer of 1 of an important treatises in meta-philosophy written within the first 1/2 the 20th century, "An Essay on Philosophical procedure" (), that is a sustained try to clarify why philosophy is an independent self-discipline with a particular process and material that vary from these of the typical and the precise.
An Essay on Philosophical Method by R. G. Collingwood,available at Book Depository with free delivery worldwide.
R.G. Collingwood, An Essay on Philosophical Method, New Edition, with an Introduction and additional material edited by James Connelly and Giuseppina D'Oro, Oxford University Press,pp, $ (hbk), ISBN An Essay on Philosophical Method contains the most sustained discussion in the twentieth century of the subject matter and method of philosophy and an unparalleled explanation of why philosophy has a distinctive domain of enquiry that differs from that of the sciences of nature.Download